There is something almost archaic in the idea that a person might give years of their life to something without knowing whether it will ever be finished. Leonard Cohen seemed to understand this instinctively. Songs could remain with him for years, neither abandoned nor entirely alive, waiting somewhere beyond the immediate demands of the world for another line, another voice, another way of entering them.
Someone once described this sensibility as an aristocracy of the intellect, a phrase that might sound faintly ridiculous now were it not for the obligation hidden inside it. Not hierarchy, nor the old theatre of cultivated superiority, but the sense that certain things should be approached with enough seriousness to alter the shape of a life; that if something has been entrusted to your attention, you may not have the right to insist that it become useful, productive or even comprehensible.
There is a peculiar dignity in remaining near something before you know what it is asking of you. Much of the work takes place away from the visible world, where apparently nothing happens and the unfinished thing begins to acquire a private existence. A sentence is left on the page, a melody disappears into silence, a painting remains covered for months, while a question follows you quietly into sleep. When you return, nothing may have been solved, although the thing itself seems to have acquired a little more weight.
Perhaps this is what becomes difficult in a culture that has grown suspicious of unproductive attention. Experience is expected to become knowledge, knowledge action, action result; even contemplation can be drawn into the same machinery, asked to justify itself by what it produces. Yet some things seem to lose their nature when pressed into usefulness. A dream does not necessarily become more valuable because it has been interpreted, a piece of music does not owe you an explanation, and there are rooms you may enter repeatedly without discovering why you are drawn to them, their significance remaining somewhere just beyond the reach of explanation.
The longer you remain with certain works, the stranger they can become. Their surfaces begin to reveal other surfaces, and what first appeared resolved opens again into uncertainty. You begin to sense the years inside them: abandoned versions, failed attempts, long intervals in which nothing seemed to happen, the possibility that the work might never become what it had promised. What you encounter is therefore not simply the finished object but something of the time that gathered around it, the silence through which it had to pass before it could emerge.
This may be why attention sometimes feels less like concentration than fidelity. You stay close without demanding disclosure, allowing the obscure and unfinished parts to remain alongside whatever can be understood. The knowledge that comes from this is rarely an answer; it is closer to a change in atmosphere, the gradual recognition that something has been taking place beyond the reach of conscious intention, perhaps even beyond the distinction between the work and the person making it.
Years later, you might discover that the work was never waiting for you to complete it so much as waiting for you to become capable of seeing what had been there all along.
There is no guarantee that such devotion will be rewarded, which may be precisely why it matters. To give yourself to something without knowing what it will return, to allow a question to become larger and less soluble rather than closing it for the sake of certainty, is to enter a different economy of time, one in which the value of a thing cannot be separated from the depth of attention it has received.
Perhaps this is another kind of wealth: not possession or achievement, but the possibility of having given something enough of your life that it no longer needs to explain itself.
And perhaps, in the end, the most valuable things remain partly in the dark.
Notitia — attending to what is not yet fully known, and allowing attention itself to become a way of being with the world.
Leave a comment